Our "All Signal, No Noise" approach
Drives an intelligence service that is succinct and timely, and is highly regarded by our time constrained client base.
Read moreLink to the page
MNI INTERVIEW: AI Productivity Gains Overhyped-Ex-CEA’s Gimbel
Read moreLink to the pageExclusives

Hopes for an AI-led productivity boom are overdone and Federal Reserve policymakers cannot count on future gains to justify not raising interest rates in the face of current high inflation, former White House Council of Economic Advisers economist and senior adviser Martha Gimbel told MNI.
“Marketwatchers have gotten too hyped up on the potentially disinflationary longer-run effects of AI. But if you say ‘we don't have to hike because you know we're going to see the disinflationary impacts of AI,’ well, who knows when it may show up?” she said in an interview.
“Second, you don't know what other issues will be going on in the world economy at the time, and whether or not those could swamp any deflationary impulse. I think it's really important not to get out over our skis over how big and when a particular inflationary or deflationary impulse will hit.”
That means Fed officials need to stay on top of the country’s ongoing inflation problem even if price rises have been supply driven, she said.
“We've seen a bunch of temporary factors that have been driving up inflation, like rising energy costs because of the war, but that keeps happening over and over again. Before the war, it was tariffs. So at some point, you just have to address the problem,” said Gimbel, who is now at the Yale Budget Lab.
DUAL MANDATE
Still, Gimbel said the Fed is understandably inclined not to tighten too quickly because the labor market, while stable, has shown momentary periods of weakness – not to mention the worry that AI could at some point displace significant numbers of workers. (See MNI POLICY: Fed To Reassess Policy After One Or Two More Hikes)
“I think the Fed really doesn't want to disturb the labor market, and the labor market's had a couple of head fakes over the last couple of years. Also they are legitimately concerned about what happens to people when they lose their job, and I think AI makes uncertainty even greater,” she said.
“But at some point, either inflation is going to need to come back down or the Fed will have to figure out how to deal with it.”
Nov-16 10:01
(Repeats story to clarify order of events)
China should arrange another summit between presidents Xi Jinping and Donald Trump in the first half of next year to stabilise bilateral ties after U.S. mid-term elections, a well-known Chinese foreign affairs expert told MNI, adding that a Democrat-controlled Congress is likely to tighten restrictions on technology exports and investment and that Beijing should resolve trade disputes with the EU in order to provide a diplomatic hedge.
The summit would aim to stabilise the current U.S.-China relationship framework and prevent potential disruptions following U.S. midterm elections from causing major rifts, said Da Wei, director of the Center for International Security and Strategy (CISS) at Tsinghua University.
According to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Monday, Xi, Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin will hold a trilateral summit on Nov 19 during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation gathering in Shenzhen.
Da said China may be willing to help de-escalate tensions in the Middle East, but the APEC summit would not be an appropriate forum for discussing the Russia-Ukraine war.
A summit in 2027 could inject greater certainty into bilateral U.S.-China ties and cover issues such as tariffs, counternarcotics cooperation on fentanyl, AI dialogue, and military-to-military exchanges, he argued. (See MNI: Trump, Xi Likely To Agree Deals On AI, Tariffs - Advisors)
Following the mid-terms, House and Senate Democrats could take a more ideological line on China than Trump, pushing for tighter controls on sensitive exports and investment as well as for arms sales to Taiwan, said Da. Revelations around the former Nvidia chief Jensen Huang could also have a considerable negative impact on the debate around controls on exports of high-end chips to China, he said.
"I can only say I hope the current relatively stable framework for bilateral relations could be maintained, though I cannot be optimistic, as disruptive factors within this framework are increasing," said Da, who has three decades of experience in China’s academic and policy community.
TAIWAN, EXPORT CONTROLS
The most critical areas of uncertainty affecting bilateral relations over the next two years are likely to be Taiwan and export controls, said Da. Tougher congressional controls could also affect other sectors beyond semiconductors and AI, he said, noting recent U.S. restrictions on investment in China's biopharmaceutical sector.
Chinese and U.S. teams are likely to meet in the near future before the leaders’ meeting to advance previously agreed-upon work, such as AI and the launch and possible expansion of the reciprocal "USD30 billion-for-USD30 billion" tariff reduction arrangement. However, resistance to opening up some U.S. economic sectors to Chinese corporate investment means that establishing a bilateral investment committee may still take time, he said.
Bumpier relations with Washington will mean China will not want major problems to also emerge in its European markets, he said, suggesting that Beijing should consider European requests for further export restraint along the lines of an agreement covering hybrid vehicles, and ensure mechanisms for dialogue with Brussels are functioning well. (See MNI: China Would Consider More EU Export Cap Requests-Advisors)
China also stands to benefit from strained EU-U.S. relations, which are unlikely to improve during the remainder of Trump's term, Da added.
Nov-16 09:11
The Bank of Japan will remain under pressure to continue raising its 1.25% policy rate regardless of external factors, as inflation expectations rise and the Bank falls behind the curve, former BOJ chief economist Seisaku Kameda told MNI.
The BOJ is already behind the curve relative to price developments, while a further yen depreciation and high crude oil prices will put the Bank in an increasingly difficult position, he explained, noting the Board will remain under pressure to raise the policy rate even if external factors do not change significantly. Consumer prices are set to rise further as the impact of a second increase in crude oil prices from around August begins to feed through to retail prices.
“The yen’s fall toward JPY160 [against the U.S. dollar] alone will not have a big impact on inflation and the BOJ’s policy interest rate as the Bank is already under pressure to raise the policy interest rate three or four times. The bank is already in a tight corner,” Kameda said, reiterating his view that the Board will hike in December, March or April 2027, followed by another increase in June or July. (See MNI INTERVIEW: Ex-BOJ's Kameda Sees 2% Rate By June)
However, should financial market volatility persist until the Dec. 17-18 meeting, the Board may vote to delay a hike until January, he warned. “Of course, there are assumptions… AI boom and the U.S. economy driven by AI demand don’t fall into considerable adjustments or into serious economic downturn.”
Markets currently see an 85% chance of a December hike, with a 1.916% policy rate priced by October 2027.
INFLATION EXPECTATIONS
Kameda said the BOJ's declaration that underlying CPI inflation had reached its 2% target is "too late,” pointing to a chart within October's Outlook Report that showed firms' inflation expectations had clearly reached the 2% target in September. (See chart)

The chart also showed that some firms expected inflation of between 4% and 6%, highlighting the upside risks to prices, Kameda noted, adding the BOJ should have provided similar data for 2025 and clarified whether expectations had reached 2% that year to support its own assessment. There is speculation that underlying CPI inflation had largely reached the 2% target in 2025, given that core CPI remained well above 2% throughout that year and 2024, he continued.
While the BOJ expected inflation to rise above 2% in its Outlook Report, it judged that the increase would be temporary and would not affect underlying CPI inflation, Kameda said. However, he added it was natural for rises in headline inflation to influence underlying CPI, despite the BOJ continuing to view this as a risk.
INFLATION TARGET
The Bank will also need to take a firmer approach to achieving its goal of stabilising underlying CPI inflation at around 2%, Kameda added, pointing to the Outlook Report, which stated that the BOJ is focused on whether 2% inflation is reflected in inflation expectations "consistent with firms' wage- and price-setting behaviour and the spread of economic practices and norms that are based on the assumption that prices will continue to rise at the rate of 2%."
“Underlying CPI inflation hasn’t been achieved in Japan and there is a view that the BOJ tolerates inflation to stay at high levels with price upside risk not only to stabilise inflation at around 2% but also to change the norm,” Kameda noted. Some argue the BOJ must devote considerable time and resources, not only to breaking past norms and customs, but also to anchoring underlying CPI inflation at around 2%, he added.
However, Kameda warned placing too much importance on this process would leave the Bank further behind the curve.
Nov-16 06:11
China should arrange another summit between presidents Xi Jinping and Donald Trump in the first half of next year to stabilise bilateral ties after U.S. mid-term elections, a well-known Chinese foreign affairs expert told MNI, adding that a Democrat-controlled Congress is likely to tighten restrictions on technology exports and investment and that Beijing should resolve trade disputes with the EU in order to provide a diplomatic hedge.
The summit would aim to stabilise the current U.S.-China relationship framework and prevent potential disruptions following U.S. midterm elections from causing major rifts, said Da Wei, director of the Center for International Security and Strategy (CISS) at Tsinghua University.
According to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Monday, President Xi Jinping, U.S. President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin will hold a trilateral summit on Nov 19 during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation gathering in Shenzhen.
Da said China may be willing to help de-escalate tensions in the Middle East, but the APEC summit would not be an appropriate forum for discussing the Russia-Ukraine war.
A summit in 2027 could inject greater certainty into bilateral U.S.-China ties and cover issues such as tariffs, counternarcotics cooperation on fentanyl, AI dialogue, and military-to-military exchanges, he argued. (See MNI: Trump, Xi Likely To Agree Deals On AI, Tariffs - Advisors)
Following the mid-terms, House and Senate Democrats could take a more ideological line on China than Trump, pushing for tighter controls on sensitive exports and investment as well as for arms sales to Taiwan, said Da. Revelations around the former Nvidia chief Jensen Huang could also have a considerable negative impact on the debate around controls on exports of high-end chips to China, he said.
"I can only say I hope the current relatively stable framework for bilateral relations could be maintained, though I cannot be optimistic, as disruptive factors within this framework are increasing," said Da, who has three decades of experience in China’s academic and policy community.
TAIWAN, EXPORT CONTROLS
The most critical areas of uncertainty affecting bilateral relations over the next two years are likely to be Taiwan and export controls, said Da. Tougher congressional controls could also affect other sectors beyond semiconductors and AI, he said, noting recent U.S. restrictions on investment in China's biopharmaceutical sector.
Chinese and U.S. teams are likely to meet in the near future before the leaders’ meeting to advance previously agreed-upon work, such as AI and the launch and possible expansion of the reciprocal "USD30 billion-for-USD30 billion" tariff reduction arrangement. However, resistance to opening up some U.S. economic sectors to Chinese corporate investment means that establishing a bilateral investment committee may still take time, he said.
Bumpier relations with Washington will mean China will not want major problems to also emerge in its European markets, he said, suggesting that Beijing should consider European requests for further export restraint along the lines of an agreement covering hybrid vehicles, and ensure mechanisms for dialogue with Brussels are functioning well. (See MNI: China Would Consider More EU Export Cap Requests-Advisors)
China also stands to benefit from strained EU-U.S. relations, which are unlikely to improve during the remainder of Trump's term, Da added.
Nov-16 01:42
Germany should revise a 2025 constitutional amendment loosening its “debt brake” on borrowing, a member of the German Council of Economic Experts told MNI, adding that national finances will get “dramatically worse” in coming years without reduced spending and higher taxes.
“The message was a very strong one,” Martin Werding said in an interview following the release on Wednesday of the GCEE’s Annual Report. “Looking ahead a few years we can see that things are going to get dramatically worse.
Chancellor Friedrich Merz, Finance Minister Lars Klingbeil and other senior ministers seem to understand the need to cut spending and boost productivity, but whether they can do so remains to be seen, Werding said.
Things will “really get worse after” 2030, he said, though Germany’s unpopular CDU-SPD coalition government “really has nothing to lose” from taking action before elections in 2029, Werding said.
“This government has opened Pandora’s box by changing our constitution and making feasible the debt financing of infrastructure on the one hand and the military on the other,” he said.
“Currently we have 2.5% of GDP financed outside the core budget, meaning that even if it were reduced at the rate of 0.25% per year it would require 10 years to be reduced to zero. In order to really make sure to make things watertight, you'd need to adjust the constitution once again, which calls for a two-thirds majority in the Bundestag.” (See MNI INTERVIEW: Germany Heads For Debt Downgrade-Watchdog Chief)
SLIM MAJORITY
A key difficulty is the government’s slim parliamentary majority, though attempts to prevent the far-right Alternative for Germany party taking power may result in an even more fractured coalition in 2029, Werding said, calling for action now.
Germany’s debt-to-GDP ratio - currently 63% - may be low compared with G7 countries, but not in relation to other EU members, Werding said, and is set to rise to 98% by 2040.
“It’s not just that we can draw a path to 100% by 2040, it’s that it does not stop there. As a Council we discussed whether the debt path might converge to some higher level, but this is certainly not guaranteed. And then there are uncertainties regarding interest rates.”
Werding was on the independent commission which recommended pension reforms that fell short of the of the GCEE’s earlier suggestions, despite constituting “huge steps” in the right direction. (See MNI INTERVIEW: German Pensions Model For EU Reform - Rocholl)
Whether they will be adopted in full is, however, doubtful.
“It is a genuine test of how, in a broader sense, the government is able to show their capacity to translate proposals into reality,” Werding said.
Measures including removing “ineffective, economically-dubious subsidies, often with negative distributive effects,” could save up to 2.2% of GDP, he said, though GCEE members could only agree on action equivalent to 1.4% of GDP - less than a third of the 4.6% needed.
Members were divided over how to raise revenue, with most stating that increases in sales and income taxes are “unavoidable” in the medium-term, though all agreed boosting productivity is vital.
HOSTILITY TO TAX RISES
“We’ve received a lot of criticism for stating that in the medium term an increase in sales and income taxes is unavoidable,” Werding said, with the centre-left hostile to raising VAT alone, and the centre-right against hiking income tax for higher earners, leaving tax policy “immobile in many places where one could do reasonable things.”
Reducing bureaucracy and regulation - alternatives to hiking taxes proposed by the GCEE’s Veronika Grimm in a dissenting opinion - remain important, Werding said, but are slow acting, and will not generate anything close to the growth needed to offset budget shortfalls and demographic change in coming years. (See MNI INTERVIEW: German GDP Underestimated - Ifo's Peichl)
“In order to close the financing gap by higher growth rates alone we'd need 8% growth on real terms for 10 years in a row, and that is simply nonsense given that our current rate of growth based on production potential is 0.5%, and that will decrease over the coming years as older people leave the labour force.”
Nov-13 13:29
The Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee needs to explain the disparity between its signalling for only limited further tightening and its much more hawkish in-house rate projections, National Institute of Economic and Social Research chief economist James Smith told MNI, adding that wage growth may exceed the Bank's expectations.
The MPC hiked Bank Rate to 4.0% at its November meeting, and has signalled that one further hike is likely. In contrast, its Monetary Policy Report’s central scenario saw the rate rising to 4.8% by Q1 2027 and peaking at 5.2%, while its adverse scenario, assuming elevated energy prices and second-round effects, has the rate peak at 6.0%.
"When you're doing this optimal path, what's really striking is you get quite aggressive increases in interest rates. They're more aggressive than suggested by the market path [which peaks at 4.9%]," Smith said in an interview. "It puts the onus on Monetary Policy Committee members to tell us how those extra paths are influencing their decision.”
If members are worried about "a period of high wage growth that gets embedded in future price rises, then ... there's a risk management argument for being more aggressive in the near term," Smith said. "But it also really increases the number of questions that you need to answer about ... [how] big the risks are and your attitude to the risks, how they feed into your decision today."
DEC OR FEB HIKE
Comments by Deputy Governor Clare Lombardelli that the Bank should "proceed gradually" with hikes, while adding that this does not preclude "back-to-back" hikes, have left the market unsure whether it will next act in December or in February.
Smith said that while it would make sense for the MPC to wait until the publication of its next Monetary Policy Report in February before its next rates increase, the economic resilience implied by Thursday's strong GDP numbers suggests a second consecutive move could be warranted.
"If we get upside surprises on inflation and the labour market next week then that creates the extra pressure for a rate rise in December and moving more quickly," he added.
STICKIER INFLATION
NIESR believes that inflation is likely to be more persistent, fed by higher-than-assumed wage growth on the back of higher energy prices.
"In the context of what's happened in recent years, there is likely to be more persistent inflation than the Bank seems to be assuming, and that's a view about inflation expectations," he said.
"The actual wage data last month were a little bit worrying. We have this very high proportion of employees that are receiving wage increases at 4% or more, and we also have some measures of the labour market that are ... [around] long run averages, so the labour market doesn't look that loose in that context," he said.
"I think we're a little bit more worried about how much inflation could be generated by the labour market."
The rates models included in the MPR will only be a baseline for the MPC, as they include simplified assumptions about the labour market, which obscure sector-by-sector variation in skill shortages and the likely shifting response of wages to inflation.
"If you were ever going to be concerned that you could get stickier and higher and more persistent inflation in the future, it's when you've just had a period of high inflation and ... you've got workers and firms who have seen the effects of that," Smith said.
He said the Office for Budget Responsibility, the official fiscal forecaster, may be underestimating wage growth. Its projections alongside the October Budget used market data taken before the recent rise in energy prices and forecast earnings growth of just 3%.
"Their peak in inflation now looks too low, and their wage growth, partly as a result of that, looks too low. I should say that there's a long-standing issue here where the OBR have had relatively low forecasts for wage growth," he said. (See MNI INTERVIEW: UK Wage Growth To Slow - OBR's Miles)
Nov-13 12:19
The biggest wild card for the U.S. economy is whether the AI boom turns to bust, sharply slowing growth and making it much easier for the Federal Reserve to pivot back to rate cuts, Yongseok Shin, executive vice president and head of business intelligence at Hyundai Motor Group, told MNI.
"That's the number one thing we are watching, and it's completely beyond our control," said Shin, economist on leave from Washington University in St. Louis and a former research fellow at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.
Shin argues that AI valuations are due for a reality check, because the speed of adoption hasn't immediately caused productivity to surge and leading AI labs have mistaken subsidized adoption for boundless demand.
By initially offering computing tokens at steep discounts, developers convinced themselves that enterprise appetite was infinite. Now, as corporate bills mount, companies are pushing back and sending routine tasks to cheaper, open-weight models rather than expensive frontier systems.
"If it's zero price, of course demand looks infinite, but that doesn't mean the price elasticity is zero," Shin said. "The AI labs may find that demand is actually very price-elastic, and their revenue projections may be a little too optimistic."
But Shin pushed back against fears that an AI correction would trigger a systemic meltdown akin to the 2008 financial crisis. Unlike 2008, AI financing is heavily concentrated in private credit and insurance companies -- institutions that aren't vulnerable to traditional bank runs. Industry giants like Nvidia are also generating substantial real cash flow, he noted.
A downturn would be "more orderly, with less panic," Shin said, largely hitting wealthy investors.
HAWKISH FED
In the meantime, Shin expects the Fed to maintain a hawkish bias as policymakers confront sticky inflation and supply-driven energy bottlenecks tied to the Middle East conflict. The central bank will likely deliver two more quarter-point rate hikes -- probably in December and again early next year -- before pausing to assess the economy, he said.
Stronger-than-expected October job growth and a hot CPI report hand the FOMC an excuse to err on the side of a slightly more restrictive posture, yet hints of labor market weakness and broader uncertainty will prevent them from doing more, Shin said.
Real wages have fallen over the last couple of months, an indication that inflation is predominantly driven by supply shocks, he said. Lower wage earners are worse off -- the long-term unemployed pool has risen and new entrants are waiting longer to get jobs. The broader U-6 measure of unemployment also edged higher last month, he said.
"If the AI investment boom implodes, who knows? At that point, it would be much easier to cut rates." (See MNI POLICY: Fed To Reassess Policy After 1 Or 2 More Hikes)
TARIFFS
Tariff-driven inflation may not be entirely past either, as foreign exporters which have absorbed the duties to protect market share still plan to recoup those costs, Shin said. Automakers importing vehicles from Japan and South Korea have generally paid the 15% tariff so far without raising prices, a position that is unsustainable given the heavy investment needed to keep pace with fast-changing technology.
But rather than hit consumers with an abrupt increase, companies plan to pass the costs along gradually.
"There will be efforts to raise prices in a very imperceptible way. So in that sense, I don't think it's really over yet. It's not like a 15% jump all at once to a new level; it works very slowly over time."
Nov-13 10:12
The Bank of Japan is considering clarifying its forward guidance as early as the Dec 17-18 meeting to give itself greater flexibility over the timing of future rate hikes and discourage markets from pricing in increases at three-month intervals, MNI understands.
The change could follow a widely expected 25-basis-point hike to 1.5% in December, although the BOJ may wait until January when it updates its medium-term economic and inflation forecasts.
Leaving the guidance unchanged risks reinforcing market expectations of further hikes in March and June or July, effectively locking the BOJ into a quarterly tightening path and restricting its policy flexibility. The BOJ does not consider such a predictable rate path appropriate, particularly as it approaches what officials may regard as a reasonable level for the policy rate. (See MNI POLICY: BOJ Unsure That Three More Hikes Needed)
While the bank does not intend to signal an end to tightening, it wants to make clear that future decisions will depend on economic and price developments rather than follow a fixed timetable.
Markets are pricing an 84% chance of a December hike and 60% odds of a further increase in March, while traders assign a 20% probability to a June hike and 33% to one in July, with the policy rate expected to reach 1.985% by October 2027.
OUTLOOK UPDATE
October's Outlook Report showed the Bank's baseline scenario assumes the policy rate will rise to around 1.75% or 2% over the projection period, without specifying the timing, while core CPI inflation stabilises around 2% after core-core inflation rises above 3% towards the beginning of the next fiscal year.
One option under consideration is to modify or remove wording found in October's policy statement referring to the risk of underlying inflation deviating above the 2% target "from materialising and thereby exerting an adverse impact on the economy afterward."
The bank is unlikely to use strong language suggesting it is well-positioned to pause, but may indicate that the policy rate is approaching an appropriate level and that it has sufficient time to assess the need for further increases.
NEUTRAL RATE
The BOJ may also reassess its estimate of the neutral interest rate, currently placed within a broad 1.1-2.5% range, using more recent economic data to signal the policy rate is approaching the midpoint and discourage market expectations of further increases.
Board member Junko Koeda's mid-October remarks that the level of the neutral interest rate "is considerably above 1%, which is roughly the lower bound of the estimated range," may reflect discussions among officials about recalibrating their assessment.
The BOJ could incorporate its thinking into the policy statement following the December meeting or communicate it through a Review, similar to its March publication, Developments in the Natural Rate of Interest and the Assessment of the Degree of Monetary Accommodation.
Nov-13 06:13
Further gradual tightening of European Central Bank monetary policy looks warranted given upside inflation risks, but the ECB’s meeting-by-meeting approach gives policymakers flexibility over by how much and when rates should rise, Governing Council member Martins Kazaks told MNI.
"In my view inflation risk is still on the upside, and given that, I see that some further tightening would be necessary given the current outlook, but by how much and when, we'll see,” said Kazaks, who is also head of the Latvian central bank
Accepting that a December hike is likely, he said uncertainty in the global economy still meant things could change.
"I think you know our reaction function very well. We're looking at a wide set of variables. We are data dependent, but we are not data point dependent," he said.
"We are not providing calendar-based guidance, because the world remains uncertain. There is more than a month to go (to the December meeting), so anything can happen.” (See MNI ECB WATCH: ECB Holds, Waiting For December Confirmation)
NOT RESTRICTIVE
The governor, speaking to MNI after a conference in Riga, said monetary policy settings were not yet restrictive, with the deposit rate at 2.5%.
"2.5% is of course somewhere near the high end for the neutral rate guide, so it's not directly slowing growth,” Kazaks said.
“That does not mean that we need some kind of sequential, large increases in rates - not at the moment,” he added.
While there are currently few if any signs of second-round price pressures, Kazaks said that the longer headline inflation remains elevated, the greater the risk becomes, although their emergence is not a given.
“I don't think that these (inflation) levels -- four, four-and a-half percent -- necessarily kick off non-linearities. It might be that at those inflation levels, it's still not a trigger for non-linearity," Kazaks said.
"But it is certainly outside the inattention area, and the longer inflation remains at those levels the more it will affect household and corporate decisions," he added. "(Inflation) above 4% … starts to push (consumer) expectations more, and I would not want to see that.”
Overall, Kazaks thinks the Governing Council has adopted the correct course.
"So far, the gradual, meeting-by-meeting, no forward guidance strategy is still the appropriate one as the overall uncertainty, especially geopolitical, remains high. So there is no need to rush," he said.
FISCAL POLICY
Referring to the impact of elevated sovereign bond yields, Kazaks said policymakers must be able to act to preserve monetary policy transmission, but that the root causes of fiscal stress must be addressed by governments.
"For monetary policy to be effective, we need a transmission mechanism that works, and that's why we have various instruments to address contagion within financial markets," he said.
However, " If the repricing is due to fiscal risks, that's the responsibility of fiscal authorities."
With leading candidates for next year’s French elections making expensive promises despite the country’s already-high debt levels, Kazaks said concerns should not be exaggerated.
"If you keep asking candidates their views in the pre-election period, it's quite likely that you will not get constructive answers, because they want to get elected," he said, without directly naming France.
"Half a year will not make or break the situation, so don't jump around unnecessarily. The market signal for the authorities is there. Wait for the next presidential elections to happen to see what the elected president decides.”
Nov-12 11:18
The Reserve Bank of New Zealand risks falling behind the curve after leaving the Official Cash Rate at 2.75% in late October, as interest rate differentials with peer economies widen, the currency weakens and imported inflation remains elevated, a former senior advisor told MNI, adding that a December hike is highly likely.
Leo Krippner, now a research fellow at Singapore Management University, questioned the wisdom of the Monetary Policy Committee’s four-three decision to hold the OCR, noting its impact on the New Zealand dollar. (See MNI RBNZ WATCH: More Hikes Still Needed Despite Hold - Breman) "When that interest rate differential gets too wide, if you've got an on-hold RBNZ versus other economies hiking, that does affect the currency, and that will come through in inflation,” he argued.
The New Zealand dollar fell around 2.3% against the U.S. dollar following the RBNZ's surprise decision, briefly dropping below USD0.56. On a trade-weighted basis, the currency dropped about 1.4% on the day and remained about 0.9% below pre-decision levels as of Nov 10, according to RBNZ data. (See chart)

“[The NZD] does actually seem quite vulnerable at this level,” Krippner said, adding that the MPC is likely to raise the OCR to 3% in December, with market pricing implying an 85% probability of such a move.
While rising unemployment, falling oil prices and spare economic capacity could give the MPC grounds to hold again, Krippner argued these factors were insufficient to outweigh persistent inflation pressures. "My pick is that they do hike in December, and I also think they should hike in December," he said.
CATCH-UP RISK
The fact that the RBNZ’s September OCR track essentially incorporated two to three additional hikes raises further questions over the October decision, Krippner said. The surprise hold pushed market interest rates lower and effectively loosened financial conditions when the Bank was seeking to contain inflation, he added.
Krippner reiterated his view that the neutral interest rate was closer to 4% than the RBNZ’s estimated 3.5-3.75%, potentially leaving the Bank with more ground to make up next year if inflation pressures persist. (See MNI INTERVIEW: RBNZ Will Need 4% OCR By Mid 2027 - Ex Advisor)
He acknowledged that estimates of the neutral rate were highly uncertain, with confidence intervals typically spanning at least one percentage point. However, persistent upside inflation surprises across economies, even after excluding energy prices, suggested neutral rates might be higher than central banks currently estimate.
“Regardless of whether you say 3.75 or 4%, or whatever number you put on it … that does suggest that central banks in general have got a bit of catch up to do, and the Reserve Bank in particular has got more catch up to do because they started from a lower point and haven't really been hiking as much as some of the other central banks.”
Markets see the OCR peaking at around 3.5% by September.
DOVISH OCTOBER
Krippner said October decision’s suggested that the MPC's approach under Governor Anna Breman is more cautious than warranted by the inflation outlook.
He questioned the Bank's emphasis on inflation coming in slightly below its September forecast, noting annual inflation of 3.7% was only 0.2 percentage point below the RBNZ's 3.9% projection, while underlying inflation measures remained around 3%. He was also unimpressed by the MPC's reference to the risk of a global economic downturn, prompted by a potential correction in artificial intelligence-related investment and equity markets, which could undermine confidence and global growth.
"But in both of those aspects, the lower than expected inflation and the risk of a downturn, those are peripheral. What's in front of you is inflation at around 3%. It doesn't look like it's going down unless you get interest rates closer to neutral and maybe above neutral."
Nov-12 01:10About
Our Head Office is in London with offices in Chicago, Washington and Beijing, as well as an on the ground presence in other major financial centres across the world.
