(BMELN; Ba1 Stable/BB+ Neg now)
- S&P Still notes the rating headroom but sees the 3 straight quarters of falling LFL sales as enough for negative outlook. As we said it is disappointing it cannot perform in this environment (as a discount). The now departed CEO was painting that as 'price positioning' that would yield results in the future (yet didn't to start this year).
- It otherwise has not flagged much concern in numbers - as we have said before co does relatively impressive margins and S&P has FOCF after leases of £300m this year and next. It has leverage ~ net 2.5x at September - we see FY/March around 2.8x. Reminder despite falling LFL sales, revenue will still see positive growth on new store openings.
- S&P does note uncertainty on new CEO's financial policy - co currently targets net ex. leases of 1.0-1.5x (= S&P net 2.5-3.0x).
- This only requires maintenance of current BS - excess cash after funding growth projects is already sent to equity holders. S&P is assuming £150-160m in dividends + £150m in buybacks or special divvy's to leave largely breakeven cash flows ahead.
- Equities are -22% YTD which may motivate more lax policy - countering that equities have a history of bouncing from levels here - sales performance likely in driver seat.
Next catalyst will be who the replacement CEO is. FY25 (to March) pre-lim results are also ahead at the end of April. Levels (£28/30/31s) already price bad news, we have no firm view here. We do not expect refi supply.