CORRECTS-MNI INTERVIEW: BCB To Cut 25BP, Near Terminal Rate

article image
Jul-30 11:23By: Larissa Garcia
Brazil Central BankBrazil

(Corrects Selic rate in first paragraph)

The Central Bank of Brazil is likely to deliver one more 25-basis-point cut next week, taking the policy rate to 14%, and then turn data-dependent for its next steps, the former head of the BCB's Department of Economic Research Marcelo Kfoury told MNI.

"There are arguments on both sides -- for keeping keep rates unchanged because the outlook remains uncertain, but also since the last Copom meeting inflation has improved, which argues in favor of another cut," said Kfoury, who participated in Copom meetings as a non-voting member until 2006 and is now a professor in the Finance Department at Fundação Getulio Vargas.

"I would cut by another 25 basis points and would make the decision for the next meeting completely data-dependent," he said, adding that the board is likely close to its terminal rate. (See MNI INTERVIEW: BCB To Cut 25BP In August, Then Pause - Velho)

"I don't think there is much room left for further rate cuts. I think we are very close to the terminal rate, at least for this year. If there is a positive surprise next year, there may be room for additional cuts. For now, I don't see much room."

The BCB cut interest rates by 25 basis points to 14.25% at its last meeting and published a paragraph, widely criticized as confusing, which simulated an interest-rate shock that would bring inflation to target in 2027, the relevant policy horizon at that meeting, but push it below 3% in 2028, the relevant horizon for the following meeting.

WINDOW OF OPPORTUNITY HAS PASSED

The real window of opportunity to cut rates has passed, Kfoury stressed. "I think the central bank should have started easing last year, when inflation was much lower. The war pushed up oil prices, which fed through to gasoline prices."

While on the one hand, inflation has improved, on the other, a stronger-than-expected El Niño is likely to put upward pressure on inflation further ahead, he said. "I think these effects will ultimately offset each other."

He added that the balance of risks to inflation remains skewed to the upside. "One thing that could have improved the outlook would have been lower oil prices, but they have risen again. So I don't think the central bank will change its balance of risks," he said.

HIGH REAL INTEREST RATE

On the other hand, interest rates are still very high, around four percentage points above the neutral rate, which means monetary policy remains highly restrictive, according to Kfoury.

"Restrictive monetary policy should be slowing the economy, but it has struggled to do so, largely because of subsidized credit," he said.

"Coordination between fiscal and monetary policy is very poor. Such a loose fiscal stance alongside such tight monetary policy is unsustainable. It is not healthy, and it will not work in the long run."

Looking ahead to next year, he said the outlook will depend heavily on fiscal policy, the outcome of October’s national elections, and the international environment. "The war in Iran has taken away about two percentage points of room that Copom otherwise would have had to cut rates,” he said.

New U.S. tariffs imposed on Brazil are unlikely to have macroeconomic effects but should instead have a sector-specific impact, he said.